In recent times, the narrative surrounding India in the Western media landscape has undergone a notably stark shiftOnce hailed as the "next China" and a pivotal player in the global realignment of supply chains, India now finds itself facing a wave of skepticismCritics have begun to question whether the country is capable of emerging as a manufacturing powerhouse and have raised alarm bells about its economic future, suggesting that India is still "light-years away" from establishing itself in this sector.

This shift in perception is largely attributed to disconcerting economic indicators that reveal a downturn in India's economic performanceGrowth projections for GDP have been revised significantly downward, with manufacturing's contribution to the GDP declining sharply and foreign direct investment plummeting.

Such skepticism raises an essential question: Is India genuinely faltering under the weight of its systemic issues, or has it merely fallen victim to unrealistic expectations set forth by its Western allies?

Historically, the U.S

Advertisements

has articulated high hopes for India, viewing it as an alternative hub for global manufacturing amidst increasing concerns over dependence on Chinese supply chainsThis ambition was formalized through strategic frameworks aimed at facilitating India’s ascendance as a manufacturing hub capable of countering China's economic influenceThe U.Sgovernment outlined its intentions through the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework, pledging to shift more supply chains to India, thus cultivating a partner that could rival China.

The basis for these expectations lies within India's rapid economic growth over the past several yearsOfficial statistics indicated that India's GDP growth outpaced that of the UK, positioning it as the fifth-largest economy in the worldFurthermore, India boasts a significant demographic advantage with a youthful and sizable workforce, where labor costs remain considerably competitive, prompting investments from multinational corporations such as Apple, which began relocating some of its iPhone production lines from China to India.

Despite these factors, the anticipated transformation of India's manufacturing sector has largely failed to materialize

Advertisements

Subsequent data has revealed that the proportion of manufacturing relative to GDP has dropped from 17% before Prime Minister Narendra Modi took office to just 14%. Alarmingly, India’s economic structure continues to lean heavily on its services sector, which remains the cornerstone of its economy.

Indeed, the service sector, prominently featuring information technology outsourcing, accounts for over 55% of India's GDPIn stark comparison, India's manufacturing sector grapples with infrastructural deficiencies, outdated technology, and an inconsistent policy environment that hampers growth and efficiency.

Rather than a robust alternative to China, Western narratives often appear to be wishful thinking in light of India's lagging infrastructure and logistical capabilitiesThe inefficiencies are glaring; for example, transporting goods from Mumbai to Delhi takes over 36 hours, while a similar route in China requires less than 12 hours.

Moreover, the limitations extend deeper into India's educational framework

Advertisements

The low enrollment rates in higher education—just 27.8% as reported by the Ministry of Education—significantly restrict the skill development of India’s labor forceThis shortcoming undercuts India’s competitiveness in high-tech industries and limits its ability to attract sophisticated manufacturing investment.

In a rather paradoxical turn of events, India has also found itself increasingly dependent on China's supply chainRecent figures showed that imports from China rose to a staggering $101.8 billion, constituting more than 15% of India’s total imports, resulting in an expanded trade deficit with China.

This dependence paints a different picture from the one projected by Western strategists, who hoped to see India ascend to a position capable of displacing China in global supply chainsInstead, these statistics reveal a concerning reality: India is intricately tethered to China for a large proportion of its supply chain requirements, complicating its positioning in the U.S.-China economic rivalry.

The changes in Western media rhetoric are symptomatic of a growing awareness of these discrepancies

• U.S. Stock Indices Decline This Week
• Europe Expected to Maintain Rate Cuts
• Impact of Non-Farm Payrolls on U.S. Stocks
• DeepSeek Drives Cloud Efficiency, Cost Reduction
• Anti-India Sentiment Rising in the U.S.?

Once embraced as a vital counterbalance to China, India now faces an increasingly critical gaze, one that questions the financial viability and future pathways available to Indian manufacturing.

Recent commentary from British publications openly lamented the challenges facing India's manufacturing sector, indicating that India could take decades to reach the level of economic competitiveness seen in ChinaThis evident disillusionment aligns with a broader reevaluation of India’s potential as a counterweight to China's economic clout.

For India, the dual pressures of economic necessity and geopolitical dynamics complicate its aspirations for the futureOn one hand, there is a pressing desire to reduce reliance on Chinese supply chains; on the other, the lack of a compelling alternative exacerbates issues of dependencyThe U.Ssupport for India remains largely at the political level, with few tangible agreements translating into actual manufacturing shifts

Despite Apple's move to relocate a fraction of its production to India, it accounts for less than 5% of their total output, underscoring China's dominant position in global supply chains.

This precarious position further clouds India’s future prospectsAs a nation of over 1.4 billion people, India theoretically possesses the potential to play a pivotal role within the global economyHowever, internal challenges paint a starkly different narrativeInstead of emerging as an independent player, India risks being perceived as a pawn in the larger game of geopolitical chess, used more to counterbalance China rather than to flourish on its own.

Ultimately, whether India can extricate itself from the role of the sidelined player hinges on a genuine commitment to internal reform, particularly in revamping its economic and infrastructural policiesAs long as fundamental barriers such as inadequate infrastructure and poor-quality labor persist, India’s quest to establish a robust manufacturing sector will likely remain a distant ambition.